文章基本信息

标题：Is petitio principii a petitio principii?
本地全文：下载
作者：J. Martín Castro-Manzano
期刊名称：Aufklärung: revista de filosofia
印刷版ISSN：2318-9428
出版年度：2018
卷号：5
期号：3
页码：21-32
DOI：10.18012/arf.2016.40801
出版社：Aufklärung: revista de filosofia
摘要：In this contribution we focus on the petitio principii fallacy and we review it under the tenets of different typical treatments. Then we submit the claim that petitio principii is indeed fallacious, not because of circularity —as the typical treatments suggest—, but because it fails to follow an order relation in Searle and Vanderveken's illocutionary logic. In other words, we claim that, although petitio principii arguments appear to be circular with respect to their propositional content, they are not circular with respect to their illocutionary acts.And hence, even when petitio principii arguments look like propositional loops and instances of reflexivity, they actually constitute a failure in an order relation, a non sequitur as it were.
关键词：Question begging; circularity; illocutionary logic; speech acts; fallacies.