文章基本信息

标题：O "Parmênides" e as doutrinas não-escritas de Platão: o Uno e o Outro
本地全文：下载
作者：Dennys Garcia Xavier
期刊名称：Voluntas
电子版ISSN：2179-3786
出版年度：2020
卷号：11
期号：1
页码：100-110
DOI：10.5902/2179378643315
出版社：Universidade Federal de Santa Maria (UFSM)
摘要：C ornford (in his Plato and Parmenides : Way of truth and Plato's Parmenides) says that the Parmenides dialogue begins "the series of works in which Plato for the first time confronts his own doctrine with the main systems of his predecessors and submits them to a critical examination "(p.63). Yes, but it is even more so: the reconstruction of the dialogue in the light of the hermeneutic method of Tübingen-Milan leads us to gather the structure in which the ontological vision on three levels intersect, from the physical world to the Ideas and from the Ideas to the First Principles. The key element of structural development is not only theoretical but also dramatic, it is the link between the two sides of the dialogue. Only the unity between the two parts makes the dialectical course recorded in the text plausible and justifiable. The first part of Parmenides brings the theory of Ideas, but gives up a Protology. Nevertheless, a complete view of the text brings into play the One and the Other/Other, foundations of the supreme Principles. The aim here is to bring to light the structural links of argument that leads us to a totalizing view of reality in Plato.↓C ornford (in his Plato and Parmenides : Way of truth and Plato's Parmenides) says that the Parmenides dialogue begins "the series of works in which Plato for the first time confronts his own doctrine with the main systems of his predecessors and submits them to a critical examination "(p.63). Yes, but it is even more so: the reconstruction of the dialogue in the light of the hermeneutic method of Tübingen-Milan leads us to gather the structure in which the ontological vision on three levels intersect, from the physical world to the Ideas and from the Ideas to the First Principles. The key element of structural development is not only theoretical but also dramatic, it is the link between the two sides of the dialogue. Only the unity between the two parts makes the dialectical course recorded in the text plausible and justifiable. The first part of Parmenides brings the theory of Ideas, but gives up a Protology. Nevertheless, a complete view of the text brings into play the One and the Other/Other, foundations of the supreme Principles. The aim here is to bring to light the structural links of argument that leads us to a totalizing view of reality in Plato↓C ornford (in his Plato and Parmenides : Way of truth and Plato's Parmenides) says that the Parmenides dialogue begins "the series of works in which Plato for the first time confronts his own doctrine with the main systems of his predecessors and submits them to a critical examination "(p.63). Yes, but it is even more so: the reconstruction of the dialogue in the light of the hermeneutic method of Tübingen-Milan leads us to gather the structure in which the ontological vision on three levels intersect, from the physical world to the Ideas and from the Ideas to the First Principles. The key element of structural development is not only theoretical but also dramatic, it is the link between the two sides of the dialogue. Only the unity between the two parts makes the dialectical course recorded in the text plausible and justifiable. The first part of Parmenides brings the theory of Ideas, but gives up a Protology. Nevertheless, a complete view of the text brings into play the One and the Other/Other, foundations of the supreme Principles. The aim here is to bring to light the structural links of argument that leads us to a totalizing view of reality in Plato.↓C ornford (in his Plato and Parmenides : Way of truth and Plato's Parmenides) says that the Parmenides dialogue begins "the series of works in which Plato for the first time confronts his own doctrine with the main systems of his predecessors and submits them to a critical examination "(p.63). Yes, but it is even more so: the reconstruction of the dialogue in the light of the hermeneutic method of Tübingen-Milan leads us to gather the structure in which the ontological vision on three levels intersect, from the physical world to the Ideas and from the Ideas to the First Principles. The key element of structural development is not only theoretical but also dramatic, it is the link between the two sides of the dialogue. Only the unity between the two parts makes the dialectical course recorded in the text plausible and justifiable. The first part of Parmenides brings the theory of Ideas, but gives up a Protology. Nevertheless, a complete view of the text brings into play the One and the Other/Other, foundations of the supreme Principles. The aim here is to bring to light the structural links of argument that leads us to a totalizing view of reality in Plato.↓Diz Cornford (em seu Plato and Parmenides : Way of truth and Plato’s Parmenides) que o diálogo Parmênides inicia “a série das obras nas quais Platão pela primeira vez confronta a sua própria doutrina com os principais sistemas dos predecessores e a submete a um exame crítico” (p. 63). Sim, mas é ainda mais: a reconstrução do diálogo à luz do método hermenêutico de Tübingen-Milão nos leva a colher a estrutura na qual se entrecruzam as visões ontológicas em três níveis, do mundo físico às Ideias e das Ideias aos Princípios primeiros. O elemento-chave do desenvolvimento estrutural não apenas teorético, mas também dramático, é o vínculo que se interpõe entre as duas partes do diálogo. Apenas a unidade entre as duas partes torna plausível e justificável o percurso dialético registrado no texto, como tentar-se-á evidenciar. A primeira parte do Parmênides traz a teoria das Ideias, mas abre mão de uma protologia. Não obstante isso, uma visão completa do texto põe em jogo o Uno e o/s Outro/Outros, fundamentos dos Princípios supremos. Buscar-se-á trazer à luz aqui os nexos estruturais da argumentação que nos leva a uma visão totalizante da realidade em Platão .
其他摘要：Cornford (in his Plato and Parmenides : Way of truth and Plato's Parmenides) says that the Parmenides dialogue begins "the series of works in which Plato for the first time confronts his own doctrine with the main systems of his predecessors and submits them to a critical examination "(p.63). Yes, but it is even more so: the reconstruction of the dialogue in the light of the hermeneutic method of Tübingen-Milan leads us to gather the structure in which the ontological vision on three levels intersect, from the physical world to the Ideas and from the Ideas to the First Principles. The key element of structural development is not only theoretical but also dramatic, it is the link between the two sides of the dialogue. Only the unity between the two parts makes the dialectical course recorded in the text plausible and justifiable. The first part of Parmenides brings the theory of Ideas, but gives up a Protology. Nevertheless, a complete view of the text brings into play the One and the Other/Other, foundations of the supreme Principles. The aim here is to bring to light the structural links of argument that leads us to a totalizing view of reality in Plato.
关键词：Parmenides;Plato;Unwritten doctrines;Parmenides;Plato;Unwritten doctrines;Parmenides;Plato;Unwritten doctrines;Parmenides;Plato;Unwritten doctrines;Parmênides;Platão;Doutrinas não;escritas
其他关键词：Parmenides;Plato;Unwritten doctrines